Skip to main content

S'witch Social vs. CRMD: An Ice Cream Showdown

 Happy Summer!

    It has been unusually hot here in Ohio for June. With these 90+ degree days, I wanted to try some non-chain ice cream places. Two of the most Instagramed ones are in Italian Village in Columbus, so we're doing a friendly head-to-head competition between S'witch Social and CRMD. 

    Up first is S'witch Social. They are known for their cookie ice cream sandwiches. I love the decor in this place. Very cute and bright. There is no seating inside, but they provide a couple benches outside. They also have a water dish outside the door for your furry friends, which always scores points. 

    You can pick any cookie, two of the same, or two different with an ice cream of your choice for your cookie sandwich. (You can check out the cookie and ice cream flavors here.) They have so many cookie options that I was torn for a while before settling on the Party Animal. It was perfect for indecisive people like me because I couldn't decide if I wanted chocolate or sprinkles. It's made with their house made cookie dough, dark chocolate, m&ms, and confetti sprinkles. I went for some strawberry ice cream and did a S'witch Sundae. The cookie was crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside, and you could taste every flavor. The ice cream was creamy and definitely not skimping on the strawberry flavor. You know how some places it's a *hint* of strawberry? That was not the case.  One friend who just got Butter Pecan ice cream said it was "a solid Butter Pecan. Very good." The other who got a S'witch Sandwich said she liked the cookies the best. It was a very satisfying sugar rush. 

    Next up is CRMD. Other than their dislike of vowels, they are known for their "puffle." The decor is black and white. There is an Instagram wall where you can take a picture with your ice cream. They also do not have tables inside, but they do have a comfy padded large bench area by the window. It was very cozy. I probably would have sat there all day. 

    The puffle is described as a puffed up waffle cone and they have unique ice cream flavors to choose from. (Check them out here.) I was hesitant about any of the colored ice creams because it just screamed food coloring to me, so I chose to go with the Choco Marsh Swirl in a puffle because I am a hardcore marshmallow lover. You also get one free topping if you'd like, and I went with Cinnamon Toast Crunch. There was definitely lots of gooey marshmallow deliciousness in the ice cream, but somehow the flavor of the ice cream itself left me missing something. This puffle though, was the star of the show. Think about if you wrapped a belgium waffle around your ice cream. That's pretty much what it is. It was soft and fluffy, yet crunchy and was so delightful. 

    The winner of this showdown is..... S'witch Social. The ice cream is so flavorful and the cookies are cooked to perfection. You can pick any cookie and any ice cream flavor and you can't go wrong. My sweet tooth was so satisfied after leaving and I've been thinking about going back ever since. Correction: It's the Party Animal cookie that I've been thinking about ever since. CRMD had some great ice cream flavor potential, but there is something lacking in flavor that leaves you wanting more. The puffle was the best thing and I don't think I'd eat the ice cream without a puffle, but I'm not going out of my way to head back there. Have you ever been to either of these ice cream places? Let me know your thoughts in the comments! 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Exploring Historic Downtown Ashland, Ohio

Hello!     I recently was feeling nostalgic and wanted to visit my old college town to see how it has changed for better or worse. I am an alum of Ashland University and I periodically miss those days, though they say you can never go back. If only. One of the things I loved about attending school there was being out in the quiet country. There was no hustle and bustle or noise of city life (or a more populated suburb). I miss the sense of peace it brought me. However, in recent years, they have built it up near the highway. More chain restaurants, apartments, and large corporations. I'm happy the college students have more options because some were really needed, but it definitely has made it noisier and ruined some of the country feel. I'm happy that the historic downtown closer to the university is being preserved with it's stunning architectural buildings and new small businesses. I wanted to take a look and see what downtown Ashland has to offer, with the help of ano...
2 comments
Read more

Primanti Bros & DeLuca's Diner

Hey All,       This month is a double feature in Pittsburgh, PA. We were in town for the P!nk concert (which was spectacular, by the way) and decided to hit up two places featured on Man vs. Food: Primanti Bros and DeLuca's Diner. Both are located in the Bar District downtown, but Primanti Bros has expanded to other locations around the state as well. These were both featured on Season 1, Episode 3 of Man vs. Food, but Adam did not do a challenge at either location. They were both his other visits prior to his challenge at Quaker Steak and Lube.       We went to Primanti Bros the first night in town. This is actually my second time going, the first was the Marketplace location downtown years ago. I have a thing for original locations, so this time I insisted on going to the Bar District. It is down a side alley street a little past the fish market. We had to wait outside briefly upon arrival, about 5 minutes, while they waited for some customers t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Mother's Day with Cravings by Chrissy Teigen

 Sending good vibes to all the moms out there. 💕      Mother's Day weekend in Ohio was full of heavy rain, cool temperatures, and comfort food cravings. Instead of going out, I decided to make my mom a day's worth of food from Chrissy Teigen's Cravings cookbook. I own both of her Cravings cookbooks and I'm highly anticipating the third because I have not made a recipe from either book that wasn't flavorful and hit the spot. Don't ask me which recipe is my favorite because that is an impossible question; although I will say in a life or death situation, it's probably in the Thai inspired section. You can order her cookbooks (and her mom's) off of her Cravings website , or at most bookstores.       In honor of Mother's Day, this is where I say a tidbit about my mom. She is the hardest working person I know. She's worked long shifts for as long as I can remember while also keeping the house clean, taking my brother to his hockey tournaments out-of-...
1 comment
Read more